Hall of Fame

1925 Water Polo Team

Sport: Water Polo
Inducted to Hall of Fame in: 2023

After the Club’s water polo team won their first AAU National title in 1920, there was a period of transition. OC Hall of Famer Sid Cavill, who had run the Club’s aquatics programs since 1899, retired from coaching at the Club in 1923 and turned leadership of the team to Frank Rivas. Rivas installed a new system which emphasized passing and speed.

Some decorated veterans continued to play, including the members who competed in the 1920 Antwerp Olympics — Jim Carson, Jack Howell and Preston Steiger; others retired. A new generation joined the Club, including OC Hall of Famer George Schroth. Schroth, like many in the aquatic programs, was both a swimmer and water polo player. It was said that “playing against him is like trying to shove a battleship.”

With the new system and infusion of players who featured well within it, the Club’s team maintained their local dominance, winning five Northern California titles in six years. Players found international success as well, with several Olympians playing for Team USA at the 1924 Olympic Games in Paris and winning a bronze medal, including “Ginger” Austin, Elmer Collett, George Mitchell and Schroth.

In 1925, the Club competed for the AAU National title in their own backyard, as the aquatics championships were hosted at the Fleishhacker Pool (then the largest swimming pool in the world, located in what is now the San Francisco Zoo parking lot). Over 150 swimmers, from 19 cities throughout the United States, Hawaii and Europe descended on the west side of San Francisco to compete, with the Illinois Athletic Club hoping to defend their title.

The 1925 OC Water Polo Team

The San Francisco Chronicle reported that “the big hope of the Olympians is, of course, to win the water polo…There is little question, but that the Winged O poloists are a better and faster squad than last year’s team.” The Club took the opening game from an Illinois team featuring decorated Olympian and future star of the 1930s and 1940s Tarzan movies, Johnny Weissmuller, 2–1. The Chronicle noted  that, “It was evident from the start that both clubs had been reported to play close and the players followed the instructions to the letter.” Steiger, the veteran goalkeeper, protected admirably, saving several goals. Weissmuller scored 30 seconds before the end of regulation; Howell sunk the winning goal in the second of two extra three-minute periods.

The OC then defeated the Chicago Athletic Club, 3–1, for the title. “George Mitchell, captain of the Olympics, played the greatest game of his career,” the Chronicle cheered. “Time and again, he took the ball
away from his opponent to carry it up the field and give the forwards the chance to tally.” Steiger “did not have as much work to do yesterday as in the first game,” as the second half of the game was “all Olympic…
the Chicago boys seemingly lost hope.”

The Olympian celebrated that “the water polo team was drenched in a spray of glory!” Later that year, the Club team defeated the Los Angeles Athletic Club, featuring the legendary Duke Kahanamoku, for the Pacific Coast title, with wins of 5–4 and 4–3. Jim Carson led the forwards with goals and the Chronicle reported that Mitchell and Schroth were “again the outstanding stars for the Olympics.” The Olympian proclaimed that the squad “saved their national championship belt, and that is a lot.”

Despite its stars, the Club would not win another AAU National water polo title until 1957. Individual players continued to find international success — Mitchell and Schroth competed for Team USA again at the 1928 Olympics in Amsterdam. Both players are in the USA Water Polo Hall of Fame.